I live in the Hamilton Park neighborhood as well and love St. Michael's. My fiance and I are planning to get married there in the spring of 2014! It's a gorgeous, rustic, welcoming Church! It's a part of the Parish of the Resurrection, which includes St. Mary's and St. Bridget's. From what I've seen, masses have a small but dedicated turnout and the priests/parishioners are lovely!! There are several young couples like us I see weekly, as well! Hope this helps - good luck!